In learning psychotherapy, we begin by following what is external. We hand our minds over to other minds and draw knowledge from them. This is very important — to gain that knowledge and to reflect on it deeply for ourselves. Behind those psychotherapeutic minds stand whole villages of practitioners, researchers, and thinkers from the field of psychotherapy. Schools of psychotherapy present to us the uniqueness of the approach we are learning, along with its past and its present, continually updated by research and practice. But that is never the end of the road. And it is not enough for us to practice psychotherapy.
As we learn psychotherapy, we also need to build our most important stances toward it. Do I see a person’s suffering as external to them, or as embedded in the context of their behavior? Does bringing spirituality into psychotherapy make sense or not? Does a therapist have the right to self-disclose to a client or not at all, and if so, under what circumstances? Is the expert on healing the client, the psychotherapist, or the two of them as a team? Is therapy based on the past, or only on the here and now? and so on and so forth. From Kornelia, one of my first trauma therapy teachers, I heard: “I can have knowledge by having listened to something and remembered it, but I can only have a stance once I have let that knowledge flow through me.” Stances are the essence of our work. And no one will ever build these stances for us. Even if the textbooks spoke to us in capital letters, we need stances of our own in order to work from within ourselves as well (and not only through techniques written by someone else).
For our work we also need universal skills that we will use regardless of the approach and regardless of the issue someone brings to us. We learn these skills gradually, as we gain experience. Nor can they be learned once and for all. The context of our work, and the context that we ourselves are, keeps changing. Something outside us and inside us is constantly shifting and calling for recalibration. Knowledge grows quickly; skills and stances, however, are built very slowly.
Every school, every successive course, every training or book can help us polish our answers to the questions our profession puts before us (let’s remember, though, that they can’t be polished once and for all, because human life — along with its difficulties — has its own innate, irremovable roughness). I think that, over time, the answers to these questions become our psychotherapeutic alphabet. The letters of this alphabet make up our therapeutic processes, particular sessions, and individual interventions within sessions. This is the axis of our work, on which we can hang our view — narrowed by the psychotherapeutic approach we have chosen — of the human being and of what supports them in healing.
- How can I listen better to the person I’m working with? Listening is not just about asking the right questions and attending to the content of the answers. Listening means separating our own assumptions about the world/the person’s mental health from what that person is actually conveying to us (through what they say, what they don’t say, what they do and don’t do, and how). To listen well, I need to recognize my own history (as a psychotherapist) and what shaped it. I have to recognize my deepest beliefs about reality and about other people. If I don’t, I will unreflectively insert my assumptions about life into what I hear from another human being. To listen well is to know yourself thoroughly, or at least well enough to know your own “that’s obvious,” “everybody does that,” “after A, B is sure to follow,” “this is forbidden/allowed.” Nota bene, this is exactly what I love contextual approaches in therapy for — for placing our beliefs (and norms!) in context rather than turning them into an absolute.
- How can I recognize the impact of what I do (or don’t do) during a session on the other person? The therapist’s behavior is their most important therapeutic tool. Their words, comments, smiles, leanings toward the client, questions, and their refraining from all of the above (and from many other responses to the client’s behavior) determine how far therapy will be a space dense with new experiences, and how far it will be a multiplication of what the client already knows all too well. So it’s worth continually learning to recognize the resonance (and dissonance) between me and the person who comes to therapy (let me add right away that resonance will not always mean we are heading in the right direction, nor dissonance that we’re heading in the wrong one; sometimes it is precisely dissonance that is the building material of change). Under what circumstances does the person’s posture open up, and when does their energy turn inward and close? What triggers a torrent of words, and what triggers silence? What brings about real change, and what merely structures the session time, leaving everything as it was? Good psychotherapists are virtuosos at noticing — on the other side (but also in their own bodies) — the micro-signals that something important is happening in therapy.
- How can I get better at noticing patterns in what emerges in a session? The repetitiveness of what the client says/does or — conversely — doesn’t do (though it would be useful to them) is important information about how they add bricks to their own well-being or suffering. Single behaviors tell us little about the client’s inner structure. It is patterns of behavior that give us the most therapeutic information. What thought precedes this person’s regularly recurring burst of existential courage? How does this person react — mentally and emotionally — to physical illness? How do they position themselves toward our therapeutic comments about their romantic life? Do these connections add up to a larger whole? What keeps being reenacted in sessions (or in the client’s life)? What role does the person we’re talking with place us in? What role do they assign to themselves? What role do they never take on? Without awareness of patterns, we are helpless as therapists. We can only react, pat people on the back, or stir up the existing order, but without much significance for the outcomes of therapy.
- How can I get better at noticing exceptions in what happens in a session? This, in turn, is something I’m grateful to my education in systemic therapy for (although systemic therapies are, come to think of it, contextual therapies too) — for drawing attention to exceptions. It is in them that we look for resources and for the invisible rules governing a person’s psychological flexibility. When is it different from what the pattern dictates? What made the person act in a completely new way? When did they behave in a way opposite to the one that describes them best?
- How do I communicate hard-to-hear observations, reflections, and hypotheses that — though uncomfortable — can be an important source of change in psychotherapy? How do I find language for what is necessary but not necessarily welcome? How can I be therapeutically honest but not cruel? How do I offer observations that come from a wish to support the person in healing, and not just from a wish to support their self-image?
- How can I deeply understand the relationship between the person I’m working with and the diagnosis they have received? Diagnoses are not innocent. Diagnoses have enormous power to influence our lives. They can open us up to our inner world, making it easier for us to function in the outer one, but they can also slam us shut to both of these worlds. In therapy, let’s never ignore what a diagnosis has made possible and/or blocked in a person’s life. And let’s revise our own beliefs about what particular diagnostic labels carry with them .
- How do I manage energy and attention during a session? What structure should I give a psychotherapy session, and how do I adapt it to the needs of a particular person? If you’ve studied with me, you know that I love a structure derived from somatic therapies, which I weave into my everyday therapeutic work (no, contrary to appearances, I don’t work only somatically, but I draw heavily on its guidance in conducting psychotherapy). That structure is orienting | resource | working with a difficult pattern | returning to the resource | exploring meaning | reorienting. And what session structure will be best in your work?
- How do I learn to see that psychotherapy is no longer needed in a person’s life? Psychotherapy is only a bridge to a life without therapy, a support for times when suffering knocks a person out, and the creation of a space in which the relationship with suffering changes. How can I spot that sessions have become superfluous? How do I communicate that my role is coming to an end? How do I negotiate a goodbye when someone expresses a wish to keep meeting indefinitely?
I wish you a beautiful journey of learning psychotherapy. Remember that this learning — even if it takes up your time and money — is an enormous privilege and an even greater responsibility. Learn in your own way, actively, with a slight disbelief in methods but with great faith in the wisdom of the person sitting across from you. And never let anyone file down the edges of your curiosity. The world needs therapists who are reflective and who keep maturing to meet the new challenges of their role!
I’m rooting for you in this process,
Sabina