***
If the stress cycle doesn’t pass through the stage where we feel its completion, the threat in our primitive brain will not go away. (Rebekah LaDyne, “The Mind-Body Stress Reset”)
***
The stress response is meant to provoke us to move. If we don’t move, the predisposition to move — called the action tendency — gets locked in our memory and shows up, for example, as involuntary tensing of the shoulder or abdominal muscles. The solution is to move and release the energy meant for fight or flight. (Glenn Schiraldi, “The Adverse Childhood Experiences… ”)
***
I see the body as a means of connecting inner and outer space. (Ursula Wirtz, “Dying and Becoming”)
***
On the sequence of our response to a stressor
The essence of a traumatic event is that we could not prepare for it sufficiently (or at all). Many of the coping strategies that are available to us and that we use all the time could not be used then, or could not be carried through to the end. This is how trauma brings chaos into the inner space of our bodies and minds and shakes our sense of influence and effectiveness. Trauma also violates our sense of identity: if I couldn’t cope (and I had always coped before), then who am I, and what am I really like? Maybe everything I used to think about myself and the world was wrong.
In non-traumatic circumstances, our way of responding to a stressor always follows the same sequence: (1) we register that the stressor is approaching, (2) we mobilize to respond to it, (3) we use that mobilization to protect ourselves from the stressor: we fight, we flee, we drive someone away or call someone over to avert a tragedy, and finally (4) we allow ourselves to discharge the energy and (5) we return — sometimes after a few seconds, minutes, or even hours — to the state of easy curiosity and relaxation we were in before the alarm went off.
In the case of traumatic events, the stressor response cycle described above may have been interrupted at any of its stages. We may have had no chance to register that danger was approaching (because, for example, at the moment the worst arrived we were asleep or had our eyes closed), or it may have been impossible for us to fight or respond to the attack in any other way (for example, we were too small for attacking/fleeing from an adult to make any sense). And it is precisely this interruption that underlies many post-traumatic consequences. What was interrupted under intensely stressful conditions is never forgotten by our nervous system; instead, it is constantly reactivated and replayed.
All the baffling reactions of our body that we observe in the aftermath of traumatic experiences — constant jumpiness and heightened vigilance, nervous gestures (tics, too!), startling in response to even a gentle stimulus, enormous fatigue after minor effort, and so on and so forth — may be consequences of an interrupted cycle of response to a traumatic event. It is this interrupted, unfinished cycle of response to trauma that makes a memory of something that happened in our life (even) years ago affect us as if we were still stuck right in the middle of the trauma.
On scanning for signals of threat
Our nervous system is constantly busy mapping our surroundings in search of signals of approaching danger (it is doing so at this very moment, too; yes, RIGHT NOW). It is especially sensitive to stimuli that remind it of the circumstances of the traumatic event (so-called triggers, triggering stimuli). If something dangerous has happened to us, the nervous system has every right to assume it will happen again. So it will watch for the smells that accompanied the traumatic event, the images, the sounds, but also bodily sensations (if, for example, we held our breath during an assault, the nervous system may effectively associate that reaction with threat), or thoughts (sometimes, a moment before a traumatic event, someone caught themselves thinking, “how beautiful and peaceful it is here”; a thought like that can also become paired with the danger that is about to come).
When the nervous system picks up in the environment even a crumb of reality linking the present with the traumatic past — it sounds the alarm. And the alarm is immediate and very violent. It may take the form of:
- automatic, highly inappropriate thoughts (e.g., “I acted like an idiot again,” “this is the end”);
- automatically triggered emotions (e.g., anger that floods us and is hard to control);
- automatic movements and/or gestures (e.g., sucking in the stomach, nervous blinking, stroking the cheek, picking at the skin, etc.)
- automatically arising somatic sensations (e.g., loss of feeling in the hands, a sensation of icy cold, etc.).
The responses to trauma stored in our implicit memory may involve one or only some of these areas, e.g., only emotions and sensations, or they may show up on all levels: sequentially (e.g., first an emotion, then a thought, then a gesture) or simultaneously (all the reactions happen at once). With each repetition of the response to a trigger, the traumatic response becomes more and more deeply rooted in our nervous system, and in an almost intact form. At the same time, this response can never complete itself. It keeps breaking off at the point where it once broke off in the past.
An unclosed traumatic response condemns us, on the one hand, to repeating it constantly and violently, and at the same time to being permanently catapulted into the reactions that accompanied the traumatic events. We keep returning — somatically, emotionally, cognitively, relationally, or existentially — to the same place. Many people affected by trauma come, over time, to perceive their automated reactions to a traumatic memory as their “true nature,” rather than as a consequence of the events that befell them. In many cases we don’t connect the trauma at all with the reaction to it that stays in our lives for months or years. This has to do with the particular nature of traumatic memory — it is heavily fragmented, incomplete, or entirely absent from explicit memory. The essence of a traumatic memory, after all, is to protect our functioning and our identity, even if that comes at the cost of our memory.
Closing the traumatic response — how will we know it has happened?
The moments when — in psychotherapy or in life — an interrupted traumatic response comes to a close cannot be mistaken for anything else. Sometimes they happen to us spontaneously and are a beautiful gift of fate; sometimes we have to put in a good deal of work around that closure (I’ll write more about this in a moment).
For a stress response to be able to close, it first has to be triggered (this closure can’t be carried out as a “dry run”). A person whose stress response was blocked at some stage has to go through it all the way to the very end.
Marianne Bentzen, in her book “Neuroaffective Meditation,” points out that moments of passage and closure are accompanied by a new quality of nervous system arousal. It is a state in which, right in the middle of mounting stress arousal, a wave of calm appears (I quote: “within strong arousal of the sympathetic branch of the autonomic nervous system, simultaneous parasympathetic arousal begins to manifest”).
Here are some of the signals that may allow us to hypothesize that the nervous system has closed an interrupted traumatic response:
- regaining a sense of agency, mobility, arousal, aliveness (this is not feverish arousal, though, but precisely a calm, life-giving aliveness and a sense of vitality);
- a sense of pride at having moved forward, at having stood face to face with our demons and not been frightened by them; I am writing here, however, about pride that is an embodied, physiological experience engaging many areas of our functioning (and not just a verbal declaration);
- a sense of being grounded and integrated; an unfinished stress response leaves us with a sense of fragmentation, disintegration, and — metaphorically or literally — no ground beneath our feet, whereas completing that response gives us more grace, support, flow, and freedom in the body;
- the return of curiosity and of an attitude of exploration and play; traumatization is accompanied by a persistent, permanent, tension-filled vigilance; when we manage to complete the stress response, our nervous system gets the signal that it no longer has to defend itself so doggedly against a repeat of the trauma and can give itself over to calmly observing its surroundings, and even to play (this shift often also becomes visible in a change in the way a person looks out at the world. “The eyes are windows to the nervous system,” write Laurence Heller and Aline LaPierre in their book “Healing Developmental Trauma”);
- a long exhale, a sigh; a blocked stress response often also involves blocked breathing; the return of deep, calm breathing may be a sign that the nervous system has finished its cycle of mobilization and is returning to parasympathetic energy (associated with free exploration, a sense of safety, regeneration);
- a change in perspective on ourselves, others, and the traumatic event; being stuck at some stage of the traumatic response also locks us into a rigid way of making meaning: we see ourselves, for example, as “helpless victims,” the world as “hostile,” and the “traumatic event” as a “curse”; the closing of the stress response is accompanied by a change at the level of meaning-making — through it we often regain a sense of our own continuity and agency and open up to other ways of seeing ourselves, and we stop experiencing the world around us as a dangerous place (in trauma therapy we also call this “reconfiguring the picture”).
How to let the nervous system finish an interrupted stress response?
For me this is probably the most beautiful part of trauma therapy, and at the same time the hardest to describe without being able to demonstrate it (I do hope, though, that if you have worked with me in a workshop, you know which moments I mean). At the same time, I know that many approaches work with completing interrupted responses (among them Gestalt, EMDR, Brainspotting, Schema Therapy, not to mention Somatic Experiencing, my study of which is the source of the knowledge behind this article), so use the pointers below to better calibrate your interventions, so that they allow your clients’ nervous systems to move beyond the traumatic loop.
What comes in handy when working on completing the response to a stressor?
- stretching the client’s response to a trigger (a triggering stimulus) out in time, slowing it down, breaking it into pieces (“granulating” it) so that, together with the client, we can notice what automatic patterns appear in their behavior and see where their response stops, “gets stuck”;
- observing macro- and micromovements in the client, exaggerating the gestures we observe, repeating them in slow motion, suggesting gestures that contrast with the one we are observing (e.g., if the client curls up in response to the trigger word “sex,” asking them to straighten up — slowly and gradually, but distinctly);
- enriching traumatic memories: “and what if, at that exact moment, your beloved grandfather had been there with you?”, “if you could have had with you, in that hardest moment, an amulet that assured you everything would turn out well for you, what would that change in your reaction to this memory?”;
- emphasizing that the traumatic event/relationship/situation is already over; after a traumatic event we need to embody the sensation of having been saved, of having survived, the triumph of living through the worst. That is why in trauma therapy I often work with a timeline, along which I move from the moments preceding the traumatic event to the moments following it (“when exactly did you feel safe?”), all the way to today, and even the future (this is a technique I have borrowed from contextual therapies and the aforementioned Somatic Experiencing).
And finally…
Trauma therapy is meant to bring more space, lightness, and flexibility into the client’s life, in place of constriction, heaviness, and rigidity. This therapy is meant to provide experiences, not intellectualization or declarations. It is meant to give the client opportunities to shift the frame through which they look at themselves, their history, and their future. I hope this text has been helpful to you in creating just that kind of therapeutic space.
Sabina Sadecka
Bibliography:
Benzten, M., (2022) Neuroaffective Meditation: A Practical Guide to Lifelong Brain Development, Emotional Growth, and Healing Trauma. Healing Arts.
LaDyne, R. (2021), Odetnij napięcie. Jak pokonać stres dzięki praktykom psychosomatycznym. Kraków: WUJ. (here is my conversation about this book for Wydawnictwo Uniwersytetu Jagiellońskiego, and here is my review of this book).
Schiraldi, G. R. (2022), Traumatyczne doświadczenia z dzieciństwa. Gdańsk: GWP.
Shershun, E. Healing Sexual Trauma Workbook (p. 5). New Harbinger Publications.
Wirtz, U. (2021), Umieranie i stawanie się. Transformacyjna moc traumy. Czeladź: Instytut Studiów Kulturowych RAVEN.