When we are all equally afraid
We are a social species, and it is in communities and through communities that our healing takes place. It is thanks to the people around us that we are able to make it through many of life’s crises and catastrophes. Relationships are our most important buffer, softening the negative consequences of the traumas we have experienced. Trauma, in turn — as Bessel van der Kolk wrote — “comes from the sense of being unseen and unheard” (Peter Levine described it as “the absence of an empathetic witness”).
Sometimes, however, tragedies and catastrophes strike not just single individuals but entire social groups or territories. A city/town/region is hit by a flood, an earthquake, a plague, an epidemic, a bombing, or a terrorist attack; a particular ethnic community is steadily intimidated, persecuted, or systematically murdered; a shooting takes place at a school; deadly tremors occur in a mine, and so on and so forth.
Collective trauma is an event or situation that affects entire populations, communities, cultures, or groups living in the same area. And just as individual trauma destabilizes the individual who experiences it, collective trauma disorganizes us collectively. As a result, we fall apart not only internally; the social fabric that until then gave us a sense of stability and predictability abruptly falls apart as well. The daily rhythm that anchored us is disrupted, the occasions and spaces for spontaneous encounters disappear, and conversations revolve only around the collective catastrophe/tragedy/loss (there is no longer any room in them for the other things that matter to us). The psychological resilience we built through people and together with people gives way to loneliness and disorientation.
“We have nervous systems designed to participate in the lives of other nervous systems,” Peter Levine said in a conversation with Thomas Hübl. They are also exceptionally prone to catching the emotional states of others. This works on us in both directions — toward ever greater regulation, as well as toward a state of inner chaos that spreads to more and more people. In the wake of collective trauma we experience, almost automatically, a spiral of emotional dysregulation multiplied by the number of people the trauma has affected. It is hard for us to look for support among our loved ones (or among the other people we would usually turn to for help), because everyone around us needs it too. In a situation of collective trauma, people enter into a mutual resonance of fear, disorientation, rage, or helplessness. The pandemic showed us this plainly: in its early stages (and not only then), tension, fear, terror, and inner chaos spread to everyone without exception (including those who, by virtue of their social and professional roles, were treating/psychologically supporting people affected by illness/grief/crisis related to the pandemic).
What are the consequences of collective trauma?
Each of us will react differently to a trauma we have lived through — even a mass one — because each of us has a different history of earlier wounds and traumatization, different factors buffering the negative consequences of trauma, and a different support network after the traumatic event. We can, however, speak of certain distinctive features that accompany traumatization of a collective nature. Below I describe a few of them for you.
Every trauma disturbs our sense of safety. If we were assaulted in a shopping mall parking lot, we may go on feeling uneasy for a long time afterward, even when we are in a completely safe situation. In a person who has experienced trauma, the (objective) state of safety abruptly parts ways with the (subjective) sense of safety. In order to heal, however, that person can slowly, in small steps, teach themselves and their nervous system that parking lots are usually safe and that their subjective sense of threat does not always match external reality (I am preparing a separate piece for you on regaining a sense of safety after trauma). In the case of collective trauma, however, the state of threat and the sense of threat merge into one. Wherever we look, we are reached by information about an (objective) threat (more people infected with the virus, an approaching bombing, undeniable signs of the climate crisis, etc.). The fear of a dangerous external situation is multiplied internally by our subjective, inner sense of threat. We no longer find shelter or solace anywhere, neither in the world outside nor in the inner, psychological one. In this way collective trauma, like no other, cuts us off from the sources of our stability and predictability. On top of that — even once the immediate danger has passed — our inner sense of threat meets the sense of threat that we (co-)feel in the people around us, which makes it even harder for us to return to the emotional state we were in before the trauma.
Most people who have experienced collective trauma may also be seriously and permanently overloaded cognitively and somatically. Their nervous systems are constantly busy simultaneously processing loss (and grief is one of the most energy-consuming psychological processes there is), coming to terms with the sense of threat, and also adapting to an entirely new reality (e.g., finding their way in life as a refugee). As a result of collective trauma we are often exhausted to the point of collapse and, at the same time, badly frightened by our own exhaustion (after all, we so desperately need energy to cope with what is new).
Collective trauma also erodes our sense of identity. Who we are is strongly defined by our relationships, our surroundings, our habits, even our daily routine, and even our physical environment. When our old life collapses like a house of cards, we become deeply lost within ourselves. “Am I still myself if in a single moment I lost my home, my family, and all my plans for the future?”, “Am I still me without being able to work out at the gym every day?”, “Am I myself if I cannot practice my profession in a new country?”, and so on and so forth. And the shakier the pillars of our identity, the smaller our reserves of psychological resilience (and so the circle of dysregulation closes).
Collective trauma also cuts us off — like no other — from our sense of agency and competence (which is closely tied to the disorientation around identity described above). People whose individual and collective lives have suddenly been demolished may feel robbed of what gave them strength, in both the material and the psychological dimension. Collective trauma is a series of losses — physical, social, emotional — combined with the impossibility of compensating for those losses with anything new and stable. A person affected by collective trauma is therefore (potentially) someone who has lost connection with what used to be the source of their power (and with their resources).
Collective tragedies also foster the emergence, within a community/group, of collective beliefs (e.g., “let’s not trust nationality X”), myths (e.g., “the flood is punishment for our pride”), and taboo subjects (e.g., the silence about the Holocaust in the first years after World War II). People affected by trauma may also succumb to collective numbness (the whole community loses hope, passively waits to be “saved,” and no longer makes any effort to improve its situation) or to a collective fight-or-flight response. So what is individual in the response to a single trauma is, in the case of a mass tragedy, replicated by the entire community affected by the traumatic event (Peter Levine called this the “collective nervous system”).
How can you support yourself (or others) in the face of collective trauma?
Collective trauma happens to communities, so healing from it should also happen IN and THROUGH communities. What matters most for people affected by such trauma is therefore sustaining, rebuilding, and reaching for bonds with other people, meeting and acting in groups, and regular, honest conversations about what happened. We do not always need psychotherapy after collective trauma, but what will help us recover faster is social support. Alicia Lieberman called this a “symphony of support,” that is, surrounding such people with the support of the local community and of psychotherapists (while placing greater emphasis on the former).
Boris Cyrulnik, in his wonderful book “Save Yourself, Life Is Calling” (I reviewed it for you here), wrote about how important it is for a person after trauma that their story be consistent with the stories of the people around them who lived through it too. “I naively believed that trauma could be explained by the war,” writes Cyrulnik. “Today I wonder whether the fact that I had to stay silent once peace came did not wound me more deeply.” Making collective trauma taboo pushes it into the community’s underground (from which it emerges at the least expected moments), whereas healing from it happens through open conversations about the hell we have been through. Wrapping collective chaos in meaning is possible only within a community, because the scale of collective trauma exceeds what a single nervous system is able to metabolize.
When supporting people after collective trauma, it is also worth making sure they realize that they managed to survive the traumatic events. Those events — although on a cognitive level we perceive them as over — are, on an emotional and somatic level, received by our brain as still going on (I also want to write more for you someday about trauma and memory). Part of the therapeutic work on trauma — and especially on a manifestation of it as disorganizing as collective trauma — is supporting the people who have been through it in realizing that the nightmare is now behind them. “You survived” is one of the most important messages in the therapy of collective trauma.
When supporting people after collective trauma, let’s also take care to rebuild their sense of continuity, predictability, stability, and connection with their life before the trauma. “You are not only a person with refugee experience; you are a man, an accountant, Maria’s son, a citizen of Europe, etc.”, “Can you tell me what you liked to eat as a child, and what you still like to eat?”, “Which words describe you best?”, “How can you build into your life at least a semblance of what your life looked like before the war/flood/epidemic?”, “What are you good at? What is your strong suit? What could I learn from you?” — these are just a few questions that can become a starting point for such supportive conversations.
“If the quintessence of trauma is that the past is always present — that yesterday’s events constantly creep into today’s thoughts — then one way to reduce the impact of adverse childhood experiences is to separate the past from the present as effectively as possible,” you will read in the remarkable book on trauma and resilience “Supernormal.” Working with collective trauma is work on boundaries, on a fuller sense of one’s separateness, but also of belonging. It is work that is both hard and beautiful, and one we need enormously in the twenty-first century. I’m rooting hard for you — those healing from such trauma and those supporting people who have been through it <3.
Sabina
I also encourage you to supplement this article with an older piece of mine, “How to Survive Hell?”
Here is an interview with me about how a teacher can support students in the face of the war going on just across our border.
https://ul.odnpoznan.pl/rozmowa-z-sabina-sadecka-o-tym-jak-odnalezc-sie-w-trudnym-czasie
I have also recorded three episodes of my podcast on collective trauma for you — I invite you to listen: